I try and make a stop whenever I'm in Staten Island! Really great food and service! You can't go wrong with their garlic knots, zeppoles, or any of their pizzas. Super thankful they remained open throughout the pandemic. Would recommend to others (and I have)!

The owner is always there and he's super friendly and nice. The food is amazing, they have pizza special every Sunday, Monday and Tuesday for 15 cash, which is a great price.

Best Pizza on Staten Island hands down. I been getting Sunset Pizza for years now. Great staff, very friendly, and they know what they're doing. If you never had Sunset Pizza you're missing out.

The pizza is so good! Not greasy or soggy super cheesy and crust is cooked to perfection. There chicken wraps are crispy and fresh and the fries are cooked to perfection and not greasy at all super delicious and fresh. Guy on the phone was also very kind the best pizza place we order from them all the time and we never have one complaint everything is always spot on delicious!

Sunset Pizzeria is a fantastic pizzeria. Sunset pizzeria has long been the subject of my curiosity as my late parents told me I went to school with the owners son. Last time I came here I had a relatively good memory of it. However, I was not completely certain of the details behind it, so I decided to come back to consummate my understanding of the place. It was an experience not to forget! What Sunset Pizzeria really distinguished itself with was the service I got. I got 1 buffalo roll, 1 pepperoni roll, 1 buffalo slice, 1 pepperoni slice and an order of Mozzerella sticks. The buffalo roll was great with good portions and a great taste even if it was as hot as Stromboli which was to be expected as it was freshly made. I have similar to say about the pepperoni roll being a good size and tasting well whilst being at a scorching temperature. The mozzerella sticks were a different shape but were functionally similar. I would say it did feel more similar to mozzarella in carozza though. The slices were massive, which is exactly how I remembered it. The buffalo slice was a bit of a bit different from what I expected but still tasted great. The pepperoni slice tasted good and met my expectations as far as a pepperoni slice goes. One of the people there, (I would describe him as having a Mediterranean complexion and a medium build with a face that can be firmly described as belonging to someone of Statentalian stock) noticed the size of my order and made it his duty and desire to give good service immediately clear. When I was trying to split the buffalo and pepperoni rolls to cool them down because they were too hot, he came and split them with a rolling pizza cutter for me which was awesome to watch. Throughout the order he doted on me to make sure everything went well, he was surprised that I was just going to eat the entire order at the pizzeria. By the end of it, he remarked that with the way I go through the food, I must be an MMA fighter. Ultimately, the food was great here but the real star of the show was the aforementioned statentalian and the amazing service he provided. Honestly he made eating there a pleasure. I'd gladly go there again if only just to see him again.

We catered a party at my house and the food was delicious. Everyone at the party said it was the best pizza and hero’s on the island.

I order pizza, I get a classic Rossville pizza. This is the "I want a pizza on Friday night" type of joint. Meatballs are home made and you can tell. They also kick annoying zoomers out of the restaurant who make a ruckus so major respect there.

We ate from sunset pizza since 1984 summer until we moved. When I'm in the area, I go back here. They have good food. The original owner was nice to us. I love their penne vodka pizza, amongst other foods I've ordered from them. Dear owner, thank you for writing me back. You would know me if you saw me in person. I was a teen when we first started going to your store. I love their penne vodka pizza.